BuildMyHOA.com
A developer’s guide to understanding the long-term financial, legal, and operational impacts of HOAs versus deed-restricted communities.
When planning a residential development, one of the key decisions developers face is whether to establish a Homeowners Association (HOA) with DCCRs (Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions) or rely solely on deed restrictions. While it might seem easier to avoid the complexities of an HOA, the long-term impact of that choice can have significant financial, legal, and operational consequences.
Without an HOA, communities often struggle with enforcement, funding for common areas, and property value retention. On the other hand, an HOA provides structured governance, ensuring that the community remains well-maintained and its property values stay high. Let’s explore the key differences.
Deed restrictions are rules attached to property deeds that limit how properties can be used and modified. These rules exist even without an HOA and are meant to maintain community standards. However, without a governing body like an HOA, enforcement becomes a challenge, leaving the burden of compliance to individual homeowners.
Although deed restrictions offer more personal freedom, they also come with drawbacks. Enforcement relies solely on neighbors or legal action, meaning that if a homeowner violates the rules, others must take them to court—a costly and time-consuming process. Additionally, common areas like parks, sidewalks, and entryways often suffer, as there is no dedicated funding or management structure to maintain them.
Another major issue is insurance and liability. If a neighborhood has shared spaces but no HOA, homeowners may find it difficult to secure casualty and liability insurance for these areas. In cases of infrastructure damage, there is no central fund to cover repairs, leaving residents vulnerable to unexpected costs.
In contrast, an HOA provides clear rules, structured enforcement, and a financial model that ensures the community remains attractive and well-maintained. This is why many cities and counties require developers to establish an HOA before approving a new subdivision.
One of the biggest advantages of an HOA is that it protects property values. By enforcing architectural and maintenance standards, HOAs prevent neighborhoods from deteriorating over time. This makes the community more appealing to homebuyers, investors, and lenders, all of whom prefer structured governance.
Additionally, HOAs provide financial stability. Homeowners contribute through assessments (dues), which fund maintenance and improvements. Unlike deed-restricted communities, where upkeep often depends on voluntary contributions, an HOA ensures that roads, landscaping, and amenities are maintained consistently.
HOAs also offer legal and regulatory advantages. Without one, a developer is responsible for enforcing deed restrictions and may face lawsuits from property owners regarding disputes. With an HOA in place, rule enforcement becomes a structured, standardized process managed by an elected board or property management company.
Moreover, HOAs reduce developer liability. When an HOA is in place, responsibility for maintaining common areas and amenities transitions away from the developer, mitigating legal risks and long-term costs.
For developers, the choice is clear. While deed restrictions offer flexibility, they create long-term financial and enforcement challenges. An HOA, backed by DCCRs, ensures that the community remains well-managed, financially stable, and legally compliant.
Without an HOA, developers risk difficulties with city approvals, infrastructure maintenance, and rule enforcement. Additionally, potential homebuyers may be hesitant to invest in a community that lacks structured oversight.
At BuildMyHOA.com, we specialize in helping developers create HOA governing documents that protect property values, streamline community management, and comply with legal requirements. Our services include:
If you're planning a new development, we can help you create a well-structured, legally sound HOA that ensures long-term success.
While some developers hesitate to establish an HOA due to upfront costs, the long-term benefits far outweigh the initial investment. An HOA-backed community offers higher property values, legal protections, financial stability, and structured rule enforcement—all of which contribute to a more sustainable and profitable development.
We handle complexities so you can focus on development. Discover how BuildMyHOA.com simplifies HOA governing documents.
